Remove Debian 12 from allowed distros
submitted by WuRui, 01:45, 25 Ιούλιος 2023
ΘΕΜΑ: maybe a bug
ΚΑΤΑΣΤΑΣΗ: opened
ΠΡΟΤΕΡΑΙΟΤΗΤΑ: medium
Περιγραφή:
Consider removing Debian 12 "bookworm" from the list of allowed distros for testing, for obvious reasons.
Μηνύματα:
desertfish123:
I also think so (since Debian12 provides some non-free firmware by default), otherwise the test results will be incorrect,
submitted by desertfish123, 08:08, 4 Ιούλιος 2024
billauger:
yes, this has been discussed on the mailing since about a year before debian 12 was released - now that it is released and we have seen it's form, it is most likely that all newly installed debian systems would be highly prone to false-positives - most hardware will "just work" and there is no easy way for the user to know if it works only because of non-free firmware - RMS also agreed that debian 12 should not be an option though it is still possible to install and maintain a libre debian system, it is not obvious how to do it - it appears that all debian ISOs now include all non-free firmwares in the debian repos, and the primary installer (the calamares GUI installer) installs all non-free firmwares onto the the user's system without mentioning that it is doing so, nor offering a way to opt out, even if the computer has no hardware which would make use of any of them though not mentioned, for completeness, debian testing and unstable also need to be deactivated for the same reason - they have existing entries associated with them; so they probably can not be removed, strictly specking, without also deleting those records debian 12 should not have been added in the first place - that complicates the situation; because it too may have gathered entries now - those should probably all be reviewed - somewhat related, i see that trisquel 11 is not an option, though it could have been added around the same time as debian 12; so this will need some sorting out - i have recently been granted admin access; and i am looking into how to address these concerns now
submitted by billauger, 10:14, 6 Ιούλιος 2024
desertfish123:
Delete the recommended debian distribution on the homepage and remind users that the testing results of this distribution since debian 12 are not reliable maybe a good solution????
submitted by desertfish123, 23:44, 3 Νοέμβριος 2024
WuRui:
@billauger,any progress so far? I think at least we could add Trisquel 11 to the list first.
submitted by WuRui, 04:05, 13 Νοέμβριος 2024

Write below your motivation

h-node.org is a hardware database project. It runs the h-source PHP software, commit cdeda15, available under the GNU General Public (GPLv3) License.
JavaScript license information